The Dolly Parton Look-Alike Contest: Cherry Grove, 1978 – When Big Hair Met Bigger Fun

In the summer of 1978, the sun shone brightly on Cherry Grove, a lively hamlet on Fire Island known for its colourful culture and knack for throwing a good party. But no one could have predicted that one sultry August evening would see an invasion of rhinestones, towering wigs, and cleavage-enhancing wizardry as contestants gathered for a Dolly Parton Look-Alike Contest.

The Origins of the Dolly Parton Look-Alike Contest

The idea for the contest allegedly sprang to life during a spirited debate at a local bar. A group of regulars, fuelled by cocktails and mutual admiration for Dolly's “coat of many colours” style, argued over who could pull off her signature look best. With a mixture of mischief and creativity, they declared, "Let's settle this the right way—with a contest!" Flyers went up, word spread, and before long, the community was abuzz with excitement.

The Big Day Arrives

The boardwalk of Cherry Grove transformed into a glittering runway, with participants arriving in everything from homemade Dolly outfits to rented gowns that would’ve made the Queen of Country herself proud. The dress code was simple: Dolly’s signature over-the-top glamour was non-negotiable. Sequins? Check. Platform heels? Essential. And, of course, a blond wig teased to high heaven was practically mandatory.

The judging panel was as eclectic as the contestants. Local drag queens, a couple of self-proclaimed country music aficionados, and even a part-time Dolly impersonator were tasked with scoring the hopefuls. The criteria? Accuracy of appearance, commitment to character, and the ability to deliver a Dolly-worthy one-liner.

A Community in Full Swing

The Dolly Parton Look-Alike Contest wasn’t just a night of laughs and dazzling costumes; it was a testament to the spirit of Cherry Grove. In a time when LGBTQ+ communities often faced hostility, events like this brought people together in celebration of individuality, artistry, and sheer joy.

Dolly herself may not have been in attendance, but if she’d seen the photos (and you know there were plenty), she would’ve undoubtedly been flattered. After all, imitation is the sincerest form of flattery—and in Cherry Grove, it came with a whole lot of sparkle.

---