The Munich Massacre: A Photographic Examination of the 1972 Olympic Tragedy
The 1972 Munich Olympics, a global celebration of athletic prowess and unity, was tragically overshadowed by a brutal act of terrorism that resulted in the deaths of eleven Israeli athletes and coaches, along with all but one of the eight terrorists involved. The attack, orchestrated by the Palestinian militant group Black September, unfolded over 23 excruciating hours and revealed grave shortcomings in counter-terrorism efforts at the time. This pivotal event would reshape global security policies and underline the need for specialized crisis management tactics in response to terrorism.
The Early Hours of Terror
On 5 September 1972, at around 4:30 AM, eight members of Black September, disguised as athletes, scaled the security fence of the Olympic Village. They made their way to the Israeli team’s accommodations in Connollystraße 31, where the horror began. Wrestling referee Yossef Gutfreund was the first to notice the intruders, and he attempted to block the door, buying precious seconds for some teammates to escape. However, the terrorists ultimately took eleven Israelis hostage, killing two almost immediately: Moshe Weinberg, a wrestling coach, and Yossef Romano, a weightlifter who tried to fight back despite being on crutches.
Inside the apartment, the remaining hostages were bound and blindfolded, trapped in a nightmare that would drag on for hours. Amid this unfolding chaos, members of the Hong Kong Olympic team, including swimmer Ronnie Wong and his coaches, narrowly escaped a similar fate by negotiating with the terrorists, identifying themselves as non-Israeli athletes.
Negotiations and The Failed Rescue Attempts
The terrorists quickly outlined their demands: the release of over 200 Palestinian prisoners held in Israel, along with two prominent German Red Army Faction members, Andreas Baader and Ulrike Meinhof. As the day wore on, negotiations led by Munich police chief Manfred Schreiber and Bavarian Interior Minister Bruno Merk focused on buying time. Offers of unlimited ransom money were dismissed by the terrorists, who chillingly stated,
"Money means nothing to us; our lives mean nothing to us."
Several attempts were made to create opportunities for rescue. In the early afternoon, a plan was devised to lead the hostages and terrorists through a basement garage of the Olympic Village to reach helicopters. The West German police positioned sharpshooters in the garage, hoping to ambush the terrorists during the transfer. However, the plan was foiled when "Issa," the terrorist leader, insisted on checking the route first. His suspicion led to a new demand: the group would travel by bus instead of walking through the garage, thus thwarting the rescue attempt.
The terrorists grew increasingly nervous as they learned of police operations through live television broadcasts. Despite police efforts to manage the crisis and the continued extensions of the terrorists’ deadlines, a viable rescue plan remained elusive.
The Transport to Fürstenfeldbruck Airbase
As the evening approached, the terrorists demanded safe passage to Cairo. The German authorities, unable to tolerate a forced transport to another country, devised a feigned agreement to fly the terrorists and hostages to Cairo. Instead, they planned a rescue attempt at Fürstenfeldbruck airbase, a NATO military installation outside Munich.
Before the transfer, the terrorists were suspicious of the vehicles provided for transport. Jürgen Kuhr, a soldier and driver assigned to assist with Olympic transport, volunteered to drive one of the minibuses to the garage for inspection. In a tense encounter, "Issa" checked the minibus for hidden dangers, peering under seats with a flashlight. Remarkably, he assured Kuhr he had nothing to fear and left the vehicle unharmed after deciding it was too small for their group.
The hostage-takers and their Israeli captives were eventually transferred to a larger bus, which took them the short distance to the waiting helicopters. By 10:06 PM, the heavily armed terrorists loaded their bound hostages onto two Bell UH-1 helicopters, ready to depart for the airbase. Four terrorists accompanied the hostages in each helicopter, ensuring complete control.
The Final Stand at Fürstenfeldbruck
The rescue operation at Fürstenfeldbruck was the last chance to free the hostages. The German authorities had stationed five sharpshooters at strategic points around the airbase, expecting only five terrorists based on previous reports. However, Munich police chief Schreiber, upon witnessing the terrorists boarding the helicopters, realised there were actually eight terrorists, not five. Crucially, he failed to relay this updated information to the operations team at Fürstenfeldbruck, a miscommunication that would have devastating consequences.
As the helicopters landed, a chaotic gunfight erupted between the terrorists and the police. Several terrorists opened fire, and one of them threw a grenade into one of the helicopters. The explosion engulfed the helicopter in flames, killing four of the hostages inside. David Berger, one of the hostages in the second helicopter, died from smoke inhalation. The other hostages had already been executed by gunfire, their bodies riddled with bullets before the final explosion. The final act of horror occurred when one terrorist raked the remaining hostages in the western helicopter with machine gun fire.
Chaos and Tragic Miscommunication
The arrival of six Mowag MR 8 police armored personnel carriers at the airbase at around 11:50 PM came too late to save the hostages. These vehicles, delayed in Munich traffic, were intended to provide cover for the police officers as they approached the helicopters. When they arrived, the police mistakenly fired upon their own sniper and the helicopter pilot, believing them to be terrorists. Both men were injured in the confusion.
Five of the terrorists, including their leaders "Issa" and "Tony," were killed during the exchange of fire. Three others, pretending to be dead, survived the shootout and were arrested. These survivors, including Jamal Al-Gashey, who had been shot through the wrist, and Mohammed Safady, who sustained a leg wound, were taken into custody.
The Media's Role and the Announcement of Tragedy
Adding to the confusion, conflicting reports circulated throughout the night. As the battle unfolded at Fürstenfeldbruck, Conrad Ahlers, a spokesperson for the German government, gave multiple TV interviews in which he described the operation as "fortunate and successful," based on premature and inaccurate information. Many news outlets initially reported that all the hostages had been saved. It wasn't until 2:55 AM on September 6 that Israel's ambassador in Bonn, Eliashiv Ben-Horin, reported the grim truth: all the hostages were dead. Mossad chief Zvi Zamir confirmed this information at 3:10 AM.
Jim McKay, covering the Olympics for ABC, delivered the heartbreaking news to millions of viewers. At 3:24 AM, after receiving confirmation, McKay somberly stated:
"When I was a kid, my father used to say, 'Our greatest hopes and our worst fears are seldom realized.' Our worst fears have been realized tonight. They've now said that there were eleven hostages. Two were killed in their rooms yesterday morning. Nine were killed at the airport tonight. They're all gone."
Aftermath and Legacy
The Munich Massacre had far-reaching consequences. Germany, shocked by the failure of its police forces to resolve the crisis, formed GSG 9, a highly trained counter-terrorism unit. On the international stage, Israel launched "Operation Wrath of God," a mission to eliminate those responsible for the Munich attack, a covert campaign that stretched across several years and involved targeted assassinations. This operation, although successful in avenging the deaths of the Israeli athletes, sparked international debate over the ethics of extrajudicial killings.
The Munich tragedy also forever changed how the world viewed terrorism. Before Munich, there was no specialized global response to hostage crises or terrorism. Governments were ill-prepared, and counter-terrorism tactics were practically nonexistent. The massacre proved to be a turning point, compelling nations to develop counter-terrorism units, revise security protocols, and invest in intelligence operations designed to preempt such atrocities.
As time passed, the Munich Massacre became a powerful symbol of the vulnerability of civilians in the face of global terrorism. It forced governments worldwide to acknowledge the growing threat of political violence and the necessity of preparedness. In Israel, the survivors of the tragedy returned home, forever scarred by the events. Shmuel Lalkin, the head of the Israeli delegation, and others like him later reflected on the trauma that came with being a survivor, standing next to the coffins of their fallen comrades at the airport in Lod, Israel, a memory that Lalkin described as the moment when the true impact of the tragedy hit him.
Fifty years on, the Munich Massacre remains a defining moment in Olympic history, forever altering the legacy of the 1972 Games. The memory of the eleven Israeli athletes who perished at the hands of terrorists continues to serve as a stark reminder of the enduring battle against terrorism, a fight that the world continues to confront today.
תגובות